Digital bureaucracy: Rethinking government in Jordan?
The achievement is not simply making a government transaction available online. It is making it shorter, reducing steps, speeding up services and ensuring decisions follow clear standards rather than varying administrative judgement. Jordan should ask not how many services have moved online, but how many steps and approvals have been removed, and how much time has been saved.
Consider a citizen applying for a government service. The application moves from an employee through several managers before reaching the director-general. Every stage may take place electronically, and the applicant may track progress online. But what has changed? The chain of approvals remains, responsibilities are divided, and the decision waits as the application moves between levels. The paper file has disappeared, but bureaucracy has simply moved from offices to screens.
This is not a technology problem; it is one of administrative design and governance. Genuine digital transformation begins before a system is purchased or an application developed. It asks why each step is necessary, what purpose each approval serves and what value it adds. Could stages be combined, removed or handled in parallel? Process re-engineering reviews transactions end to end, identifies delays and duplication, redistributes authority and responsibility, and digitizes the redesigned process rather than automating the old one.
This does not mean abolishing oversight or bypassing procedures required by law. Some approvals protect public funds and ensure legality. Each administrative level should have a clear legal, supervisory or technical purpose, within documented limits and subject to accountability.
Jordan's experience offers a foundation. According to the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia (ESCWA), Jordan's score in the Government Electronic and Mobile Services Maturity Index rose from 63 per cent in 2024 to 71 per cent in 2025. The next stage should measure not simply whether services are online, but how much they simplify lives. Digital service numbers indicate reach, not necessarily efficiency. We should measure eliminated steps and signatures, time saved and applications completed correctly the first time.
Jordan's Digital Transformation Strategy and Executive Plan for 2026–2028 provide an important framework, emphasising service redesign, process re-engineering and stronger integration among government institutions.
Data governance is essential. Citizens should not have to provide a document that another government institution already holds and can verify lawfully and securely through data exchange. But sharing data must not mean unrestricted access. It requires a defined purpose and legal basis, clear access permissions, accountability for accuracy and effective protection. Easier procedures must not compromise citizens' privacy or rights.
Artificial intelligence could take this work further. It can analyses transaction flows, identify bottlenecks, forecast demand and help allocate resources. It can check applications, classify requests and support employees in applying service standards. But an algorithm must not reject applications or determine eligibility as an opaque authority, without a legal basis, human oversight, an explainable decision and a right to review and appeal. The aim is smarter administration, not transferring unchecked discretion from an employee to a system.
Jordan does not need to transfer bureaucracy into cyberspace; it needs to use technology to reform bureaucracy itself. Citizens do not care whether applications travel between offices or screens. They care about receiving their entitlements without needless complexity, delay or discrimination. The real test is not watching an application move electronically between officials. It is having the institutional and legal courage to ask why it needs so many stops—and remove those serving no necessary purpose. Digital transformation does not begin when administration appears on a screen; it begins when we redesign it to work better for everyone.
The achievement is not simply making a government transaction available online. It is making it shorter, reducing steps, speeding up services and ensuring decisions follow clear standards rather than varying administrative judgement. Jordan should ask not how many services have moved online, but how many steps and approvals have been removed, and how much time has been saved.
Consider a citizen applying for a government service. The application moves from an employee through several managers before reaching the director-general. Every stage may take place electronically, and the applicant may track progress online. But what has changed? The chain of approvals remains, responsibilities are divided, and the decision waits as the application moves between levels. The paper file has disappeared, but bureaucracy has simply moved from offices to screens.
This is not a technology problem; it is one of administrative design and governance. Genuine digital transformation begins before a system is purchased or an application developed. It asks why each step is necessary, what purpose each approval serves and what value it adds. Could stages be combined, removed or handled in parallel? Process re-engineering reviews transactions end to end, identifies delays and duplication, redistributes authority and responsibility, and digitizes the redesigned process rather than automating the old one.
This does not mean abolishing oversight or bypassing procedures required by law. Some approvals protect public funds and ensure legality. Each administrative level should have a clear legal, supervisory or technical purpose, within documented limits and subject to accountability.
Jordan's experience offers a foundation. According to the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia (ESCWA), Jordan's score in the Government Electronic and Mobile Services Maturity Index rose from 63 per cent in 2024 to 71 per cent in 2025. The next stage should measure not simply whether services are online, but how much they simplify lives. Digital service numbers indicate reach, not necessarily efficiency. We should measure eliminated steps and signatures, time saved and applications completed correctly the first time.
Jordan's Digital Transformation Strategy and Executive Plan for 2026–2028 provide an important framework, emphasising service redesign, process re-engineering and stronger integration among government institutions.
Data governance is essential. Citizens should not have to provide a document that another government institution already holds and can verify lawfully and securely through data exchange. But sharing data must not mean unrestricted access. It requires a defined purpose and legal basis, clear access permissions, accountability for accuracy and effective protection. Easier procedures must not compromise citizens' privacy or rights.
Artificial intelligence could take this work further. It can analyses transaction flows, identify bottlenecks, forecast demand and help allocate resources. It can check applications, classify requests and support employees in applying service standards. But an algorithm must not reject applications or determine eligibility as an opaque authority, without a legal basis, human oversight, an explainable decision and a right to review and appeal. The aim is smarter administration, not transferring unchecked discretion from an employee to a system.
Jordan does not need to transfer bureaucracy into cyberspace; it needs to use technology to reform bureaucracy itself. Citizens do not care whether applications travel between offices or screens. They care about receiving their entitlements without needless complexity, delay or discrimination. The real test is not watching an application move electronically between officials. It is having the institutional and legal courage to ask why it needs so many stops—and remove those serving no necessary purpose. Digital transformation does not begin when administration appears on a screen; it begins when we redesign it to work better for everyone.
The achievement is not simply making a government transaction available online. It is making it shorter, reducing steps, speeding up services and ensuring decisions follow clear standards rather than varying administrative judgement. Jordan should ask not how many services have moved online, but how many steps and approvals have been removed, and how much time has been saved.
Consider a citizen applying for a government service. The application moves from an employee through several managers before reaching the director-general. Every stage may take place electronically, and the applicant may track progress online. But what has changed? The chain of approvals remains, responsibilities are divided, and the decision waits as the application moves between levels. The paper file has disappeared, but bureaucracy has simply moved from offices to screens.
This is not a technology problem; it is one of administrative design and governance. Genuine digital transformation begins before a system is purchased or an application developed. It asks why each step is necessary, what purpose each approval serves and what value it adds. Could stages be combined, removed or handled in parallel? Process re-engineering reviews transactions end to end, identifies delays and duplication, redistributes authority and responsibility, and digitizes the redesigned process rather than automating the old one.
This does not mean abolishing oversight or bypassing procedures required by law. Some approvals protect public funds and ensure legality. Each administrative level should have a clear legal, supervisory or technical purpose, within documented limits and subject to accountability.
Jordan's experience offers a foundation. According to the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia (ESCWA), Jordan's score in the Government Electronic and Mobile Services Maturity Index rose from 63 per cent in 2024 to 71 per cent in 2025. The next stage should measure not simply whether services are online, but how much they simplify lives. Digital service numbers indicate reach, not necessarily efficiency. We should measure eliminated steps and signatures, time saved and applications completed correctly the first time.
Jordan's Digital Transformation Strategy and Executive Plan for 2026–2028 provide an important framework, emphasising service redesign, process re-engineering and stronger integration among government institutions.
Data governance is essential. Citizens should not have to provide a document that another government institution already holds and can verify lawfully and securely through data exchange. But sharing data must not mean unrestricted access. It requires a defined purpose and legal basis, clear access permissions, accountability for accuracy and effective protection. Easier procedures must not compromise citizens' privacy or rights.
Artificial intelligence could take this work further. It can analyses transaction flows, identify bottlenecks, forecast demand and help allocate resources. It can check applications, classify requests and support employees in applying service standards. But an algorithm must not reject applications or determine eligibility as an opaque authority, without a legal basis, human oversight, an explainable decision and a right to review and appeal. The aim is smarter administration, not transferring unchecked discretion from an employee to a system.
Jordan does not need to transfer bureaucracy into cyberspace; it needs to use technology to reform bureaucracy itself. Citizens do not care whether applications travel between offices or screens. They care about receiving their entitlements without needless complexity, delay or discrimination. The real test is not watching an application move electronically between officials. It is having the institutional and legal courage to ask why it needs so many stops—and remove those serving no necessary purpose. Digital transformation does not begin when administration appears on a screen; it begins when we redesign it to work better for everyone.
comments
Digital bureaucracy: Rethinking government in Jordan?
comments